Get It promo

Author defends Butte death rates work

2012-04-29T02:30:00Z Author defends Butte death rates workBy Nick Gevock of The Montana Standard Mtstandard.com

Butte badly needs more health studies to determine how effective the cleanup of mining waste has been.

On that point, the federal Environmental Protection Agency, Atlantic-Richfield Co. (ARCO), Butte-Silver Bow County and Stacie Barry agree.

But Barry, a Butte native whose doctoral dissertation studies the mortality of Butte residents, said she’s fed up with federal officials and ARCO trying to discredit her work.

Her study, which has received a lot of attention in recent months, used a statistical analysis of Centers for Disease Control data and found that Butte has higher-than-average death rates from cancer and a host of other diseases.

“It didn’t set out to be the be-all and end-all epidemiology study in Butte,” Barry said this week in her office at the National Center for Appropriate Technology, where she works as director of energy services.

Barry, 39, said nothing in her dissertation claimed a direct cause from the pollution caused by decades of mining. And she conceded that the study has shortcomings, mainly its lack of age adjusting to further break it down.

But she stands behind the work and said it’s been frustrating to see that EPA and ARCO have sharply criticized her work as scientifically unsound through opinion pieces and statements in the newspaper.

She said if anything, her dissertation will serve to get Butte talking about environmental health in the largest Superfund cleanup site in the country, something she feels is long overdue. That’s been witnessed by numerous emails and telephone calls that Barry said she’s received from people throughout town thanking her for raising the issue.

“It’s this giant elephant in the room that somebody is finally talking about,” Barry said.

ARCO RESPONSE

Barry’s mortality study has drawn attention, but in fact it was only part of her dissertation. She also looked at the environmental history of the Butte Superfund site, as well as cultural factors that could affect death rates in the Mining City. But it’s been her mortality study portion of the dissertation that has drawn tremendous attention.

ARCO has criticized Barry’s methodology, calling it “fundamentally flawed.” And this week, ARCO issued a 41-page paper critiquing Barry’s work that pointed out what it saw as shortcomings.

Cord Harris, ARCO spokesman, said Barry’s report was broad in scope.

“It was an overall look at health in Butte,” he said. “Usually you look at one disease, but in Butte it was all of them.”

SHARP CRITIQUE

Environ International Corp., a Seattle firm hired by ARCO, conducted the critique. Among other things, it criticized Barry for not adjusting the mortality records to consider age. And it said she didn’t adjust for gender as well, which Barry said she in fact did.

In addition, the critique said a health study in Butte should look at disease incidence and not mortality to try to measure the effect of toxins on health. And it questioned numerous other portions of Barry’s study.

Julie DalSoglio, Montana EPA director, said the agency found problems with Barry’s report as well. EPA is drafting a written review that will be released soon.

But she said EPA is supportive of more extensive studies to gauge health issues in Butte.

“It is important for the county to do a health study and to look at cancer incidences and other health incidences throughout the county,” she said. “From EPA’s perspective, it is important to design the studies in a way that can address some of the issues in terms of how to look at the data and we hope to work with the county to do that.”

STUDIES NEEDED

Barry said the EPA and ARCO are right.

“I agree that we need many, many studies and I think this is just the tip of the iceberg,” she said. “And I do think the age adjusting is a good idea; it would shed more light on what’s going on here.”

But she said that doesn’t justify the way both EPA and ARCO have responded to her study. She said the EPA worked to have a response to her study ready when it was released.

“It was definitely expressed to me that EPA did not like what I was doing,” she said.

And she defends her work. The lack of age adjusting was purposeful because Barry said had she done that, the sample size for each age category would have been too small to be statistically sound.

She also adjusted her study for gender, despite claims that she didn’t. And she took into account other factors that affect health, such as alcohol abuse. At the same time, Barry stresses she never stated the toxins found in Butte were causing disease because that’s not scientifically sound.

PUBLIC SPOTLIGHT

Barry added a health incidence study is badly needed, but those records are difficult to look at because of federal privacy laws. Her study used death records that were readily available because it was feasible.

Despite the attention, Barry, who holds a doctorate in interdisciplinary studies from the University of Montana, said she is a private person who was not seeking to be in the limelight. Nor does she enjoy it.

But as a Butte native with numerous relatives here, she takes pride in opening the discussion about environmental health issues in Butte. She said if the public speaks out, it can make more money available to conduct sound, scientific studies of the health issues.

“It’s a conversation in Butte that people have wanted to have, but they didn’t necessarily have an avenue to express it,” she said. “I’m glad that I at least opened the dialogue.”

— Reporter Nick Gevock may be reached at nick.gevock@mtstandard.com

Read it yourself

To read Stacie Barry’s dissertation abstract, see this story at www.mt

standard.com, and click on the dissertation link.

(6) Comments

  1. EcoRover
    Report Abuse
    EcoRover - April 30, 2012 7:40 pm
    ARCO and EPA (are they the same entity?) always find it easier to shoot the messenger rather than listen to the message. ARCO has a long history of using hired guns such as Environ International Corporation to greenwash ARCO's deeds and to defend ARCO against criticism. With the public attention brought by Dr. Barry's work, maybe now ARCO/EPA will use its money to honestly evaluate the Butte health problem rather than just covering it up?
  2. butteisthebestplaceonearth
    Report Abuse
    butteisthebestplaceonearth - April 30, 2012 6:33 am
    They say if you only have three months to live, move to butte for the winter, it will seem like ETERNITY

  3. annd
    Report Abuse
    annd - April 29, 2012 11:05 am
    People say things like "just because we seemingly have a lot of ill people doesn't mean it correlates to the environmental toxins... we don't have the data to support that" -- in a town this size, with people who can communicate through lots of differing means ... guess what? We know people are sick, and it's documented very well what these toxins do to our bodies. Why are they so eager to discredit Stacie -- because they don't want to hear it. People are not the major concern, money and power are. It's unfortunate that the powers-that-be don't like the results of something, they try to tear it down. And, the symbiotic relationship that exists between British Petroleum (ARCO), EPA...the Health Dept. They just want it to go away. Well, we're questioning and due to Stacie's report... we now have some answers. I wish they'd use differing terms than not just implying, but stating, it's "flawed" -- they want to point out anything that takes the credibility away -- we know better. Her research is very sound, and some high-powered people have been involved with it, people who are very trust-worthy
  4. Buckminster
    Report Abuse
    Buckminster - April 29, 2012 11:04 am
    Follow the money. That's one of the first things you have to do in this controversy. Barry admits her study is not the be-all and end-all. Methinks ARCO and the EPA protesteth too much.
  5. 7525226
    Report Abuse
    7525226 - April 29, 2012 8:28 am
    I VERY quickly looked at the thesis on-line and was disturbed by some errors in what could be considered the trivial facts. I know these don't always effect the meat and bones but when the little things, that can easily be fact checked, are off it causes me to question the bigger things more closely. One example that sticks in my head is that she lists Mike Mansfield as being born and raised in Butte (very trivial I know). A quick Google search will confirm that he was born in New York (as will the other non-electronic sources such as Don Oberdorfer's book among many others). Hopefully she does not take all comments as attacks and all parties can look at the work to see how it can be useful to address questions and concerns. However there are some that won't believe any facts just their opinions. I know there will be further scrutiny that will address and perhaps correct some of the minor things which will add credence to the bigger picture.
  6. fellowworker
    Report Abuse
    fellowworker - April 29, 2012 8:22 am
    Thank you, Stacie Barry, for opening this can of worms. It is high time for a closer look at the effectiveness of the remediation efforts thus far, and especially the action levels set for the residential metals program. My kid's health depends on it! The criticism and resistance from the MEPA does not instill much confidence in their objectives, it will be the citizens who must insist on a higher standard.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Copyright 2012 Mtstandard.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Follow the Montana Standard

Facebook

The Montana Standard on Facebook

Twitter

The Montana Standard on Twitter

Email

Get email updates from The Montana Standard

Email Updates

RSS

Follow The Montana Standard via RSS

RSS Feeds

Find Events

Featured Business Offers

Shea Realtors

We have a great new listing in Uptown Butte - Find real estate in Butte MT with Shea Realtors

This older style brick house is completely renovated.  On the …

Regan Financial Services, Inc

Call Regan Financial Services for Boat, RV and Motorcycle Insurance in Butte MT

  Call us today to compare your RV, boat, and motorcycle insur…

Steele's Furniture

Don't miss the Ekornes sales event! Get up to $1500 off furniture in Butte MT at Steele's!

Get up to $1500 off* Stressless® product when you buy any Stre…

Wells Fargo Home Mortgage

Contact Wells Fargo Home Mortgage in Butte MT for a free home buying consultation!

Contact us today and start the homebuying process with a free …

Employment Marketplace

Featured Businesses

Poll

Loading…

Do TV's political attack ads influence you?

View Results