Get It promo

Letter: EPA was wrong to scoff at Barry’s report on Butte

2012-04-08T00:00:00Z Letter: EPA was wrong to scoff at Barry’s report on Butte
April 08, 2012 12:00 am

I read with interest the letter to the editor written by Julie DalSoglio, Montana Office Director of the Environmental Protection Agency, concerning her response to "a report questioning the protectiveness of EPA action levels and cleanup activities." DalSoglio specifically quotes this report released by Stacie Barry, In reality, this “report” is actually the dissertation researched and written by Stacie Barry, who successfully defended such dissertation to a broad range of academia earlier this year in pursuit of her doctorate degree at University of Montana. Although I’ve not studied this dissertation, I can feel confident that the “science and findings of the report” were severely tested at her presentation. The Montana University system does not issue doctorate degrees light heartedly or irresponsibly.

The debate over Barry’s findings should and will continue, for the end result must be a safer, cleaner, and better Butte. My concern now is for the integrity of the EPA. Julie DalSoglio has either not done her research and is simply mistaken, or is taking this debate to the gutter by personally minimizing another individual's accomplishments. Dr. Barry is deserving of an apology, at the least. More important, to me, is the question: “If Julie DalSoglio is so cavalier with the truth regarding the “report” and its source that she quotes in her letter to the editor of April 1, can I trust her when she tells me about the EPA’s accomplishments and commitment to Butte?

Ronald Chatriand

226 Carousel Way


(2) Comments

  1. annd
    Report Abuse
    annd - May 04, 2012 10:56 am
    Stacie has taken a lot of heat over her dissertation. Mostly due to EPA, ARCO and Health Dept. She has my respect, and admiration
  2. capnbutch
    Report Abuse
    capnbutch - April 08, 2012 7:07 am
    Thanks for this excellent letter. There is need for many more like it.

    Nobody doubts EPA's yearning for a better planet. Unfortunately EPA officers are publicists and lawyers. Very few are scientists. There often are failures in the sciences and therefore failures of integrity.

    The agency has held some huge hearings and called for massive citizen input. The same agency was the object of a very special congressional hearing.

    In each case, EPA resolutely ignores findings.

    It's nobody's fault really. These things will happen in any federal organization that has no oversight.

    All that is left that we can do is to provide greater citizen involvement. That includes the generation of teams to gain publicity and push the agency. It is little understood that EPA gives massive grants to private organizations that are willing to propose defense of environment.

    If the good doctor got a few people behind her, there would be good money in it and perhaps some success.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Copyright 2012 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Featured Business Offers

Shea Realtors

We have a great new listing in Uptown Butte - Find real estate in Butte MT with Shea Realtors

This older style brick house is completely renovated.  On the …

Regan Financial Services, Inc

Call Regan Financial Services for Boat, RV and Motorcycle Insurance in Butte MT

  Call us today to compare your RV, boat, and motorcycle insur…

Steele's Furniture

Don't miss the Ekornes sales event! Get up to $1500 off furniture in Butte MT at Steele's!

Get up to $1500 off* Stressless® product when you buy any Stre…

Wells Fargo Home Mortgage

Contact Wells Fargo Home Mortgage in Butte MT for a free home buying consultation!

Contact us today and start the homebuying process with a free …

Employment Marketplace

Featured Businesses



Do TV's political attack ads influence you?

View Results